Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Fortunately we're seeing more JS DB libraries offering to read large numbers as the BigInt type.


But frustratingly, a JS BigInt is nothing like a BigInt in any other language.

In JS - BigInt is 64bit integer.

In anything else - BigInt is a arbitrarily large integer.


Hm? JavaScript BigInts are arbitrary precision, and you need to use methods like BigInt.asIntN(64, a) to convert them to 64 bits


I hate this so much because you can’t nicely serialise a BigInt as JSON. Using a string is nicer but it only makes sense where int64 is used as an ID, not where it’s used as a number; and you don’t wanna have to configure this per field per query.


You can serialize a BigInt by specifying a replacer:

    const obj = { a: 9007199254740993n }
    JSON.stringify(obj, (_key, value) => typeof value === 'bigint' ? JSON.rawJSON(value.toString()) : value)


And then you end up with strings on the other side, not numbers.


No you don't? The example I gave produces

    {"a":9007199254740993}
not

    {"a":"9007199254740993"}


Oh, that's much worse! The JSON string `{"a":9007199254740993}` decodes to the object `{"a":9007199254740992}` with typical JSON parsers like JavaScript's `JSON.parse`.


If you're applying a replacer, then you'd supply a reviver when parsing:

    const json = '{ "a": 9007199254740993 }'
    JSON.parse(json, (_key, value, context) => /^\d+$/.test(context.source) ? BigInt(context.source) : value)


Yeah but now you have the world's biggest foot gun in your API.


IMO, I'm tending toward thinking that having types on your readable serialization format is a mistake, and that they should be always input to the (de)serializer instead.


JSON has arbitrary length numbers in the spec only.


Completely and utterly irrelevant.


This is simply not true? Or maybe I misunderstand what you mean?




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: